ask us a question on permitted development           Permitted Development England
How to build a home extension  without Planning Permission using your PD rights - Oct. 1st 2008

  

 

Home Page About Us FAQ Advertise on this site Disclaimer Privacy Contact Us Site Map

Use of a property - What some of the Appeal Inspectors have said on C of LD Appeals relating to this issue.

This appeal decision summary and assessment has been produced by Planning Jungle Limited.  For more information, please go to  www.planningjungle.com/?p=20

 

THE 'USE' OF A PROPERTY EITHER CURRENT, HISTORICAL OR PROPOSED IN PLANNING TERMS IS ANOTHER HOT POTATOE THAT CAN BECOME A VERY TECHNICAL ISSUE.

 

Various other types of appeal decisions are not summarised in these appeal listings. For example, these include appeals relating to the “use” of a property (e.g. applications for certificates on the basis that a use has become lawful through the passage of time), and appeals relating to other Parts of the GPDO. Please note that this list was started at the end of 2009, and therefore only contains appeal decisions after this date.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

NOT SUMMARISED IN THIS DOCUMENT - OTHER: 

Decision Date: 

Address: 

PINS Reference: 

Reason for not including in this document: 

Notes: 

22 September 2009 

Bungalow Farm, Penrhos 

APP/Q6810/X/08/2090105 

Abandonment of a single family dwellinghouse. 

The Inspector concluded that the use of the property as a single family dwellinghouse had been abandoned. 

2 October 2009 

Bellepool, Clewshaw Lane 

APP/P1805/X/09/2097017 

Part 2, Class A 

The Inspector found that a 3m wide grass verge next to a road formed part of the “highway”.  Therefore, a 2m high wall along the front boundary of the property next to this grass verge was not permitted development. 

8 October 2009 

83 Grove Lane 

APP/A5840/X/09/2098889 

Previous Part 1, Class A. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

12 October 2009 

3 Redcliffe Street 

APP/K5600/X/09/2099309 

Previous Part 1, Class A. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 October 2009 

16 Bassett Heath Avenue 

APP/D1780/X/09/2097252 

Use of the rear-most detached out-building as managers accommodation ancillary to the use of the main house as a house in multiple occupation. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 October 2009 

Shaves Plantation, Brighton Road 

APP/D3830/X/08/2087041 

Proposed Forestry Work Unit 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 October 2009 

The Noor, Yeovil Road 

APP/F1230/X/09/2094936 

Non Compliance with the Agricultural Occupancy Condition 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

20 October 2009 

Oaktree Farm 

Drummau Road 

APP/Y6930/X/09/2098219 

Certificate of Lawfulness for an existing residential unit 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

27 October 2009 

Ankorn Cottage, Bell Green Lane 

APP/P1805/X/09/2108666 

Conversion of detached garage to additional ancillary accommodation within planning unit. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

27 October 2009 

16 Zinzan Street 

APP/E0345/X/08/2093169 

Use of building as 4 No self contained apartments (i.e. Four Dwellings). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

27 October 2009 

4 Green Lane 

APP/Y3940/X/09/2101666 

Part 2, Class B 

The Inspector assessed the proposed means of access against the phrase “create an obstruction to the view of persons using any highway used by vehicular traffic, so as to be likely to cause danger to such persons”, and found that it would not be permitted development. 

27 October 2009 

Bedford Bridge 

Horrabridge 

APP/J9497/X/09/2105079 

Part 8, Class A. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

29 October 2009 

Middle Colgate Farm, Ham Road 

APP/B1605/X/09/2097334 

Use of the barn as a single dwelling house 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

2 November 2009 

Camp Alyn, Tafarn-y-Gelyn 

APP/R6830/X/09/2096943 

The retention and continuation of existing residential accommodation. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

4 November 2009 

1 Woodrows Cottage 

APP/W0340/X/09/2096853 

Change of use of land from agricultural to residential garden 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

4 November 2009 

The Lodge 

Truslers Hill Lane 

APP/D3830/X/09/2105805 

Private leisure use and occasional overnight holiday accommodation 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

5 November 2009 

Flight Service Station, Bridgwater Road 

APP/D0121/X/09/2109226 

Proposed use 

of the site for washing/valeting cars, dropping off and picking up cars, associated retail and administration 

Appeal dismissed. 

5 November 2009 

Oak House Farm 

Newgatestreet Road 

APP/W1905/X/09/2099334 

Dwelling house 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

6 November 2009 

Rudley Oaks, Chelmsford Road 

APP/X1545/X/09/2097918 

Residential use for land comprising three parcels of land on which the buildings thereon have been used for residential use. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

10 November 2009 

29 Ascham Place 

APP/T1410/X/09/2107436 

Part 2, Class A. 

The property has an existing curved boundary wall at the corner of two highways, and the certificate was to erect a 1.7m wall immediately behind (abutting) the existing one.  The Inspector concluded that the proposed wall would be “adjacent to a highway”, and therefore not permitted development. 

11 November 2009 

267 East India Dock Road 

APP/E5900/X/09/2097561 

Eastern flank wall mounted lightbox hoarding measuring 6 x 3 x 0.4 metres. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

12 November 2009 

44 Arundel Drive East 

APP/Q1445/X/09/2098191 

Previous Part 1 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

12 November 2009 

Homefield, Moss Lane 

APP/P2365/X/09/2109940 

Two static caravans within the curtilage of a dwelling for use as sleeping accommodation ancillary to that dwelling. 

The Inspector concluded that the caravans are not operations development, because they are capable of being moved, and not a material change of use, because their use as sleeping accommodation would be ancillary (not incidental) to the use of the dwelling. 

16 November 2009 

115 Spotland Road 

Case Summary for APP/P4225/X/09/2108212 

Use as a furniture store (Class A1). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 November 2009 

Land comprising field at, OS Grid Reference 417427 457161 

APP/E2734/X/09/2108955 

Whether a certificate could be issued for development that contravened a requirement of an enforcement notice then in force, where the enforcement notice had been issued, but was not yet “in effect”, due to there being an appeal in progress against the enforcement notice. 

The Inspector stated that an enforcement notice is “in force” from the date that it is issued, and therefore dismissed the appeal. 

17 November 2009 

75 Ringstead Road 

APP/C5690/X/09/2099971 

Use as a single family dwellinghouse 

At the date of application for an LDCP, property was in the process of being converted into flats (unlawfully), and the Inspector agreed that the property did not benefit from Part 1 rights. 

17 November 2009 

163 Grove Road, 

APP/U5930/X/09/2100515 

Previous Part 1. 

This case concerned the 5m separation distance of the previous Class E. 

23 November 2009 

Dromenagh Farm 

Seven Hills Road 

APP/N0410/X/09/2100011 

Change of use to builders contractors yard with associated parking, storage and on site equipment training facilities. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

24 November 2009 

Manor Farm 

Prescott 

APP/G1630/X/09/2102416 

The use of the land for the shooting of shotguns for more than 28 days per year 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

26 November 2009 

5 Clough Lane 

APP/B3438/X/09/2106822 

Permission for the sports pavilion 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

26 November 2009 

Plots 2/3 Esbies Estate 

APP/J1915/X/09/2095205 

Use as a residential caravan site without complying with Condition 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

26 November 2009 

40 - 41 Esbies Estate 

APP/J1915/X/09/2095197 

Use of land as a residential caravan site without complying with Condition 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

26 November 2009 

42-43 Esbies Estate 

APP/J1915/X/09/2095199 

Use of land as a residential caravan site and for the erection of stables. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

26 November 2009 

Plot 46, Esbies Estate 

APP/J1915/X/09/2095202 

Use as a residential caravan site with no limitation on the duration of residential occupation in any one year 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

30 November 2009 

Vale Farm 

Phelps Lane 

APP/Y3940/X/09/2102712 

Storage of touring caravans 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

30 November 2009 

Shellen Valley Farm 

Layhams Road 

APP/G5180/X/09/2103538 

Replacement mobile home 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

30 November 2009 

Shellen Valley Farm 

Layhams Road 

APP/G5180/X/09/2103539 

Use of existing mobile home as residential accommodation and side/rear extension 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

2 December 2009 

Gilfach Holiday Villlage, LLwyncelyn 

APP/D6820/X/09/2108817 

The Change of use of a building as a dwelling house 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

2 December 2009 

Gilfach Holiday Village 

APP/D6820/X/09/2100070 

Use of buildings as 42 dwelling houses 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

2 December 2009 

Totternhoe Lime Works 

Lower End 

APP/P0240/X/09/2101301 

For any use falling within Class B2 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

2 December 2009 

151 Wavertree Road 

APP/N5660/X/09/2104136 

Previous Part 1. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

4 December 2009 

Dumbills Farm, Crosshall Brow 

APP/P2365/X/09/2109887 

Whether the location of two proposed outbuildings was part of the “curtilage” of the dwellinghouse. 

The Inspector concluded that the location was part of the “curtilage” of the dwellinghouse. 

7 December 2009 

The Shamba, Lyndhurst Road 

APP/B9506/X/09/2096649 

Use of the Land as garden / residential curtilage 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

8 December 2009 

82 Wakeman Road 

APP/T5150/X/09/2100225 

Whether works had commenced (/started/begun) prior to 01/10/2008. 

The Inspector concluded that the excavation, although small, seems to have been a reasonable exploration as to foundation requirements, and that the works amounted to a start of the development. 

9 December 2009 

Bredhurst adoption centre, Matts Hill Road 

APP/A2280/X/09/2108375 

The provision of a temporary caravan in the grounds at the rear to provide staff welfare facility. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

9 December 2009 

Tafarn Bach Farm, Trerhingyll 

APP/Z6950/X/09/2109455 

Whether conditions restricting the occupation of a dwellinghouse to persons employed in agriculture or forestry had been breached for a continuous period of at least 10 years. 

The Inspector found that the continued residential use of the dwelling without complying with the agricultural occupancy conditions had become lawful. 

10 December 2009 

Walnut Tree Farm 

Addington Lane 

APP/H2265/X/09/2101077 

Use of land for residential garden 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

21 December 2009 

Old Hall Farm, White House Lane 

APP/L2630/X/09/2100215  

Continued use of land as domestic garden  

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

21 December 2009 

Tanyard Farm
Woodhill Lane 

APP/R3650/X/09/2100314  

The retention of an ancillary outbuilding.  

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

21 December 2009 

Land adjacent to Jay Riding School, Low Common 

APP/E3525/X/09/2106897  

Temporary siting of a mobile laying ark  

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

22 December 2009 

2 Lane Green Road  

APP/C3430/X/09/2101795  

Sale of farm produce from trailer at front of site.  

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

22 December 2009 

129 Queensway  

APP/G5180/X/09/2113129  

A3 restaurant use  

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

22 December 2009 

Pouchen End Farm House
Pouchen End Lane 

APP/A1910/X/09/2108970  

Erection of detached shed – but concerned previous Part 1 and whether land was within the “curtilage” of a dwellinghouse.  

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

23 December 2009 

Honeyfields, Theobalds Park  

APP/W1905/X/09/2097182  

Certificate of Lawfulness for an existing agricultural storage building  

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

30 December 2009 

Oak Tree Farm  

APP/G2245/X/09/2100906 

Replacement mobile home  

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

30 December 2009 

9 Dinam Park  

APP/L6940/X/09/2106695 

Proposed conservatory – under Previous Part 1 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

4 January 2010 

The Smithy
Hampton Loade 

APP/L3245/X/09/2099134 

Residential caravan site accommodating six caravans  

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

11 January 2010 

Penweathers Vean, Penweathers 

APP/D0840/X/08/2085904 

Vehicular access. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

11 January 2010 

Mortons Dairy, Kenyons Lane 

APP/M4320/X/09/2104157 

Use of the land in connection with a dairy business involving the parking and manoeuvring of cars and commercial vehicles, storage of plant and equipment, storage of out of service milk floats and storage of other dairy related items 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

11 January 2010 

Rob Rosa, Lower Road 

APP/B1550/X/09/2111555 

Use of a timber framed building as a single dwelling 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

14 January 2010 

40 Avenue Road 

APP/U1240/X/09/2109068 

Replacement front porch – appeal dealt with whether alterations to porch constituted “development” – Inspector concluded not development. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

14 January 2010 

14 Zealand Avenue 

APP/R5510/X/09/2108697 

Single storey rear extension for use as exercise room, involving demolition of existing outbuilding – appeal dealt with whether rebuilding of outbuilding constituted development – Inspector concluded was development. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

14 January 2010 

1 Shirehall Close 

APP/N5090/X/09/2106181 

Kitchen extension at ground floor , Roof extension to rear of property (2 dormers) – begun before 01/10/2008 and assessed under previous Part 1. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

15 January 2010 

23 First Avenue 

APP/D1590/X/09/2101304 

Use of the property as a dwellinghouse 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

21 January 2010 

Ty Bychan, Pant Du Road 

APP/R6830/X/09/2111015 

Static Residential Caravan 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

25 January 2010 

177 Wentworth Road 

APP/F5540/X/09/2114111 

Erection of canopy 

The Inspector concluded that an LDCE could not be issued because, at the date of the application, the operations contravened the requirements of an enforcement notice then in force.  The Inspector states that the date that an enforcement notice comes into force is the date that it is issued (i.e. the earlier date, rather than the later date that it comes into effect). 

28 January 2010 

Langstone Court Bungalow, Langstone Court Road 

APP/G6935/X/09/2108819 

Detached bungalow with garden & paddock 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

1 February 

161 Hever Avenue 

APP/G2245/X/09/2115846 

Garage conversion into habitable room – dealt with whether this would be contrary to a condition on a previous planning permission. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

3 February 2009 

Trefullock Cottage, Trefullock Moor 

APP/D0840/X/09/2103141 

Use as a dwelling 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

4 February 2009 

5 Kingston Lodge 

APP/D0121/X/09/2100992 

Use of property as self contained flat 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

(Remember to save appeal decision notice) 

 

 

 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 


11 February 2010  

Wildacres 

Green Dene 

APP/Y3615/X/09/2110583 

LDC to establish whether planning permission is required for the alteration of the existing structure on site to form a caravan ancillary to the use of the dwellinghouse 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

11 February 2010 

Plot 11, Highcroft 

APP/C1625/X/09/2113862 

Construct a dwelling in the grounds of Highcroft, plot 11 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 February 2010 

433-435, 441 and 443 and 445 to 447 

Mansfield Road 

APP/Q3060/X/09/2115970 

Use of premises for the display of advertisements 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

17 February 2010 

321 Turton Road 

APP/T4210/X/09/2111804 

Proposed single storey side and rear extension – but appeal revolved around whether existing “dwelling” is lawful, rather than around Part 1. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

19 February 2010 

Post Mill Farm, Benwick Road 

APP/D0515/X/09/2109465 

The use of Post Mill Farm as a residential dwelling house and ancillary garden area. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

23 February 2010 

Copperfields, Windwhistle Ridge 

APP/R3325/X/09/2115917 

The proposed erection of a garage/machinery store – but appeal revolved around whether original planning permission for house and associated s106 agreement were valid. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

24 February 2010 

Haven Farm, Lamb Lane 

APP/P4415/X/09/2117129 

Proposed conversion of cow shed to dwelling 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

25 February 2010 

29 The Ridgeway 

APP/C1950/X/09/2108956 

Enlargement of existing bedroom at first floor comprising alterations to roof, removal of dormer and first floor rear extension – appeal decision revolved around the date that the original house was created for GPDO purposes 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

1 March 2010 

Railway Arches 431-434 Kingsland Viaduct & 1-3 Cotton's Gardens 

APP/U5360/X/09/2111387 

Nightclub and premises 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

1 March 2010 

Valley View, Hemel Hempstead Road 

APP/P0240/X/09/2111119 

The use of the land for the siting of four caravans for residential use. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

1 March 2010 

Dennington Caravan Park, Delamere Road 

APP/A0665/X/09/2109738 

Use of land as a permanent residential caravan site. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

2 March 2010 

The Barn, Coldblow Lane 

APP/Z2260/X/09/2104546 

Use of property as open commercial use. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

9 March 2010 

Tintagel Farm 

Sandhurst Road 

APP/X0360/X/09/2117496 

The siting of mobile home as living accommodation 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

9 March 2010 

85a Fitzjohns Avenue 

APP/X5210/X/09/2106980 

Use of the lower ground floor as a self-contained residential flat (Class C3). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

9 March 2010 

Garden Cottage, Cockbury Court 

APP/G1630/X/09/2105930 

Occupation of Garden Cottage in breach of condition (f) of T333f/F/1 (holiday let condition). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

11 March 2010 

Ty Draw Farm,  

Peterston-super-Ely 

APP/Z6950/X/09/2114103 

The existing use of the former agricultural land/paddock (approx 0.5ha) is domestic garden. The use of this land as a garden commenced more than 10 years ago (14 years) and its use as a garden has been continuous throughout this period 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

11 March 2010 

Box Hedge Farm, Box Hedge Lane 

APP/P0119/X/09/2103938 

Use of land for corporate events and activity days, team building events ans stag and hen activity days and vehicle parking for participants and staff 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 March 2010 

Manor Farm, Towthorpe 

APP/C2741/X/09/2118509 

The siting of a mobile home within the curtilage of Manor Farm. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 March 2010 

10 Dellfield Close, Radlett 

APP/N1920/X/09/2111285 

Rear balcony and railings – the former was assessed against the 10 year rule and the latter against the previous Part 1. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

17 March 2010 

Southview, 22 Ham Road 

APP/U3935/X/09/2115288 

Residential use 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

18 March 2010 

16 St. Pirans Road 

APP/D0840/X/09/2106440 

Use for the stationing of a residential caravan 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

23 March 2010 

Mill House, Mill Lane 

APP/X2220/X/09/2119343 

Works to existing store building: new double doors and windows; new conservation rooflights; removal of existing front door replacing with brickwork: associated works: new hardstanding for car parking; new hardstanding for yard to annexe; stone steps to annexe; metal railings and brick walls 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

24 March 2010 

23 Beech Rise 

APP/Q3115/X/09/2114032 

The erection of a balcony above the flat roof extension to the rear of the property – was assessed against the previous version of Part 1. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

24 March 2010 

Ashview, Hamlet Hill 

APP/J1535/X/09/2112205 

Use of land to include storage of no more than three caravans 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

24 March 2010 

Sandyway Sandyway Woods, Lanlivery 

APP/D0840/X/09/2103602 

Use as a single dwellinghouse with associated parking and turning area with utility buildings and lawned garden area 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

31 March 2010 

Church House Hotel, 50 Rowsham Dell 

APP/Y0435/X/09/2117580 

The existing use of the property as a 10 bedroom guest house with one staff bedroom (in breach of Condition 6 of Planning Permission Reference MK/90/241 for use as six bedroom guest house) 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

31 March 2010 

Church House Hotel, 50 Rowsham Dell 

APP/Y0435/X/09/2104802 

Use of the property as a 10 bedroom guest house with one staff bedroom 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

1 April 2010 

Old Bexley Equestrian Training Centre, Vicarage Road 

APP/D5120/X/09/2115913 

Use of a brick built building as a single dwelling. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

12 April 2010 

4 Bournefield 

APP/H1705/X/09/2106324 

Residential use as a garden 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

13 April 2010 

The Croft, Tickhill Lane 

APP/B3438/X/09/2115105 

The occupation of the croft as a dwelling house 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

14 April 2010 

Leisure Park Real Estate, Woodlands Park 

APP/E2205/X/09/2118771 

Use of existing residential caravan park for up to 180 residential mobile homes. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 April 2010 

New Farm, Buckworth Road 

APP/H0520/X/09/2108670 

Use as a dwelling house without any restrictions 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 April 2010 

Land rear of 247-255 Tyldesley Road 

APP/V4250/X/09/2108937 

Application for Lawful Use of land for a period of 10 years or more for the storage and repair of vehicles and storage of building materials 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 April 2010 

125 Manfield 

APP/P2365/X/10/2120381 

Proposed erection of 2 metre high boundary fence 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

19 April 2010 

Windemere, 3 Keysfield Road 

APP/X1165/X/09/2107641 

Use of 2 caravans/portacabin and mobile home 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

19 April 2010 

Oakland Farm, Hollins Lane 

APP/F2360/X/09/2109224 

The use of a static caravan as a permanent residential dwelling 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

19 April 2010 

427 Uttoxeter Road 

APP/B3438/X/09/2109874 

Existing use of land as edged red is residential curtilage 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

19 April 2010 

Arzu House, 1 New Row 

APP/T5150/X/09/2112574 

Retention of existing dwellinghouse with 11 bedrooms 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

19 April 2010 

Sycamore House Farm, High Lane 

APP/P2365/X/09/2114343 

Use of land as car parking area. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

22 April 2010 

Brosterfield Caravan Park, Foolow 

APP/M9496/X/09/2105897 

Use for the unrestricted all year round occupation of 20 caravans falling within the statutory definition (ie to include mobile "Park" homes). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

26 April 2010 

16a Hawthorn Road 

APP/P5870/X/09/2109558 

The property has been in use as a self contained private domestic dwelling between 1993 and 2010 and has not had a change of use during the period 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

26 April 2010 

Foxes Green Farm, Foxwist Green 

APP/A0665/X/09/2107986 

Domestic garden 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

26 April 2010 

Nos. 5 & 6, Pen Villa, Isleham Road 

APP/H3510/X/09/2102131 

Use of the building known as No. 6, The Barn, Pen Villa as a single dwelling house from the main dwelling house known as Pen Villa, Isleham Road, Worlington. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

26 April 2010 

Glenfield, Hurst Lane 

APP/Q3630/C/09/2115757 

Stationing of 11 caravans/mobile homes 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

26 April 2010 

Glenfield, Hurst Lane 

APP/Q3630/X/09/2099712 

Use of land and buildings for the manufacture and distribution of ice 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

28 April 2010 

Machell Place Stables, 48 Old Station Road 

APP/H3510/X/09/2110964 

Conversion of trainer's house to 2 semi-detached houses 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

4 May 2010 

Oakwood, Chawleigh Week 

APP/Y1138/X/09/2115915 

Conversion of barn to dwelling 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

5 May 2010 

Paddock Woods, Petworth Road 

APP/R3650/X/09/2118631 

Use of outbuilding as living accommodation (a "granny annexe") ancillary and incidental to the enjoyment of the dwellinghouse, use class C3 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

6 May 2010 

Barn 1, Middle Southcott, 

APP/Q1153/X/09/2110577 

Use of converted barn as unrestricted residential dwelling 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

13 May 2010 

The Cottage, Padd Farm, Hurst Lane 

APP/Q3630/X/09/2108399 

Change of use of building to a single self-contained dwelling (Class C3). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

17 May 2010 

Bandits Keep, 28 Church Lane 

APP/J0405/X/09/2111055 

Continued use of annexe building as a separate unit of accommodation. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

20 May 2010 

Rew Lane, Martinstown 

APP/F1230/X/09/2115926 

The use of the land for the storage of furniture, building materials, containers and vehicles inside and out. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

20 May 2010 

Herons Green, Dorchester Road 

APP/U1240/C/09/2117584
APP/U1240/C/09/2117585 

Use of the chalet structure or cabin at the appeal site as a shed ancillary to the enjoyment of the dwelling house at the appeal site 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

21 May 2010 

69e Victoria Road 

APP/D2510/X/09/2112049 

Use of the property as a dwelling, Class C3 : Dwelling Houses as defined in The Town and Country Planning (Use Classes) Order 1987 as amended. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

24 May 2010 

Bugsell Park, Bugsell Lane 

APP/U1430/X/09/2112116 

Lawful use of land edged red on plan 1 as a residential garden within the domestic curtilage of the main house. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

26 May 2010 

Higher Trevibban Farm 

APP/D0840/X/09/2110282 

The screening of subsoil excavated on site and imported materials. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

27 May 2010 

110-122 Botley Road 

APP/G3110/X/09/2117240
APP/G3110/X/09/2117114 

Use of the entire building for unrestricted Class A1 use. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

1 June 2010 

11 Martindale Road 

APP/F5540/X/09/2111397 

The continued use of part of the premises as an office (solicitor). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

3 June 2010 

26 Bulmershe Road 

APP/E0345/X/10/2120803 

Lawful Development Certificate for existing use of house as a dwelling house 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

15 June 2010 

The Pool House, Rear of Mill House 

APP/V2255/X/09/2117243 

Use of building as a dwelling house (C3). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

15 June 2010 

Rear of The Oaks, Lenham Road 

APP/U2235/X/09/2116683 

Application for a lawful development certificate for an existing use being residential garden space a use which began more than 10 years before the date of this application. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 June 2010 

17 Whittington Road 

APP/Y5420/X/09/2118053 

Use of property for 6 persons living together as a single household. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

17 June 2010 

Nursery Copse Farm, Church Hill 

APP/W0340/X/09/2109237 

Hard surfaced farm yard for storage of hay, straw, manure and farm vehicles and trailers. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

 

 

 

 

 

22 June 2010  

Welwyn, 33 Lower Hampton Road 

APP/Z3635/X/09/2116538 

Existing use of site and original building as a single dwelling unit 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

24 June 2010  

Daytona Sandown Park , More Lane 

APP/K3605/X/09/2114378 

Continuous use of floodlights, public address system, extend opening hours and various kart types contrary to planning permissions 1995/1317 and 1997/0259 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

24 June 2010  

Land rear of Boundary Villa Farm, Boundary Lane 

APP/R0660/X/09/2117436 

Use as residential garden 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

28 June 2010  

Monkshatch Garden Farm, Hogs Back 

APP/Y3615/X/09/2116400 

Certificate of Lawfulness for an existing use to establish whether the building and associated land has been used as a single dwelling house for more than four years before the date of this application. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

8 July 2010  

Unit 16, Swan Vale Industrial Estate, Colchester Road 

APP/Z1510/X/09/2116904 

Use of the unit as unrestricted open retail use (Use Class A1). 

The description of development referred to “DIY store” but no condition was imposed restricting the use to just this particular type of A1 use.  The Inspector concluded that such a reference in the description of development is not sufficient in itself to prevent other A1 uses.  No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

8 July 2010  

5 Elm Lawn Close 

APP/R5510/X/09/2118312 

Use of outbuilding as residential accommodation. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

13 July 2010  

Wellington Hall, Wellington Hill 

APP/J1535/X/09/2118462 

Proposed use as hospital (on former Youth Hostel Site). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

13 July 2010  

Meadowview Park , St. Osyth Road, Little Clacton 

APP/P1560/X/09/2115466 

Extension and redevelopment of a holiday camp - sui generis - (as granted planning permission on 9 January 1976 - appeal ref: APP/5520/A/74/10875; planning permission ref: TEN/613/74). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

14 July 2010  

53 Bryn Castell 

APP/T6905/X/09/2112735 

Extension of curtilage to dwelling. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 July 2010  

97 Manor Waye 

APP/R5510/X/09/2116893 

Existing use of a dwellinghouse to 1 x three-bedroom and 1 x one-bedroom self-contained flats. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 July 2010  

Pinstone Way , Tatling End 

APP/N0410/X/09/2118302 

Storage of containers : Vehicle Storage 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

19 July 2010  

Garden Centre, 9 Lees Lane 

APP/R0660/X/09/2115961 

Use of the site as a garden centre 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

21 July 2010  

10 Nuthatch Close, Creekmoor, Poole BH17 7XR 

APP/Q1255/X/10/2121248 

Part 40, Class A - To create an array of photovoltaic panels in roof. 

The Inspector looked at conditions A.2(a) and A.2(b), and allowed the appeal. 

26 July 2010  

Days Lane, Pilgrims Hatch 

APP/H1515/X/09/2118817 

Use of building as a residential dwelling. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

27 July 2010  

Sanders Park , Sampford Courtenay 

APP/Q1153/X/09/2118664 

Use of land and building for storage, distribution, builders yard and production / mixing of lime based products and associated activities. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

28 July 2010  

Monkshatch Garden Farm, Hogs Back 

APP/Y3615/X/09/2116400 

Certificate of Lawfulness for an existing use to establish whether the building and associated land has been used as a single dwelling house for more than four years before the date of this application. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

28 July 2010  

The Pool House, St Briavel's Common 

APP/P1615/X/09/2118356 

Use of The Pool House as a separate dwelling unit. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

29 July 2010  

Land on corner of Frating Road and Brundells, Great Bromley 

APP/P1560/X/10/2120653 

Siting of caravan for shelter and erection of shed; and use of land for leisure / recreational uses. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

3 August 2010  

Lilac Cottage, Malthouse Lane, Caerleon NP18 3SL 

APP/G6935/X/09/2118587 

Welsh case – dealt with whether permitted development rights had been removed by condition. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

9 August 2010  

Old Gore Wood, Old Gore Lane 

APP/Q3305/X/10/2122587 

Use of the land as a 32 pitch touring caravan site and ancillary development in accordance with outline consent ref : 039866/002 and reserved matters approval, ref: 039866/005 granted in 1976 and 1979 respectively (DEL). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

9 August 2010  

Dunkirk , Aylsham 

APP/K2610/X/10/2121413 

Industrial Units at Aylsham. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

13 August 2010  

Willow Cottage, South Hay 

APP/M1710/X/10/2130178 

Dwellinghouse built in accordance with planning permissions 38551/001 & 38552/002. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

18 August 2010  

Adjacent Shafford House, Childwickbury 

APP/M1900/X/09/2117956 

The recycling of non toxic skip waste, the composting and recycling of green garden waste and for the storage of building materials and the storage and repair of machinery and vehicles. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

19 August 2010  

69 Effingham Road  

APP/Y5420/X/10/2121567 

Retention of property as two self contained flats. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

19 August 2010  

Old Wesleyan Chapel, Carricks Hill 

APP/U1430/X/10/2126765 

Lawful use of the building as a residential dwelling 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

20 August 2010  

120 / 122 Stoney Lane, Rear of Sparkbrook 

APP/P4605/X/10/2121866 

Existing use as garage business 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

24 August 2010  

Gordon House, Stelling Minnis 

APP/L2250/X/10/2123601 

Exixting use of land as garden land 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

24 August 2010  

Evergreen Farm, Partridge Lane 

APP/B3600/X/10/2121231 

The use at the site of one roll on/roll off container skip. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

2 September 2010  

Heol Draw, Tretower 

APP/P9502/X/10/2128352 

Residential use of dwelling and ancillary residential use of outbuildings along with residential use of curtilage, as identified with the site edged red. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

2 September 2010  

Hawthorne Cottage, Hawthorne Lane, Rowledge, Farnham, Surrey GU10 4DJ 

APP/R3650/X/09/2114933 

Construction of a first floor extension as approved by permission reference FAR/418/61. 

Dealt with whether a planning permission granted in the 1960s could be said to be partially implemented such that the remaining works (first floor extension) could be undertaken 50 years later.  

7 September 2010  

12 Hillcrest Road , Biggin Hill, Westerham, Kent, TN16 3TY 

APP/G5180/X/09/2117078 

Erection of means of enclosure (swimming pool) – the development was undertaken prior to the current version of Part 1, and in any case was subject to enforcement notices that had not been appealed and are now in effect. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

15 September 2010  

64 Great Thrift, Petts Wood, Orpington, Kent, BR5 1NG 

APP/G5180/X/09/2118423 

“Single storey building at rear for use as triple garage and store” – assessment revolved around an assessment of the extent of the “curtilage” of the property. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

15 September 2010  

301A Shirland Road, London W9 3JL 

APP/X5990/X/09/2118977 

“Raise roof (grey slate mansard) or wall (flat roof) at application site to no more than 3 metres from ground level (nothing else changes)”.  The Council refused the COL on the grounds that PD rights had been removed by a condition on a previous planning permission – the appellant tried to argue that the condition was invalid.  Appeal dismissed. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

15 September 2010  

28-30 Trinity Street , Halstead, CO9 1JA  

APP/Z1510/X/10/2121235 

Continued use of building as A3, A5, D2 (Children’s indoor play area with café). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 September 2010  

Dells Farm, Batemans Lane, Wythall, Birmingham B47 5DF 

APP/P1805/X/10/2123027 

Use of ancillary amenity space to accommodate the stationing of an additional 8 caravans for residential purposes 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

23 September 2010  

Downsview Nursery South, New Hall Lane, Small Dole, BN5 9YJ 

APP/Z3825/C/10/2121311 

The use of an agricultural building as a single dwelling house. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

23 September 2010  

Unit 9, Avoncroft Cattle Breeders Site, Buntsford Hill, Bromsgrove B60 3AS 

APP/P1805/X/10/2120453 

Proposed use of building for purposes falling within B1/B2 and B8 uses. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

23 September 2010  

Stacklands Retreat House, School Lane, West Kingsdown, Sevenoaks, Kent, TN15 6AN 

APP/G2245/X/09/2119650 

Completion of retreat building. 

Contains the quote: “I agree that, were it the case that development pursuant to permission 3928 had been commenced in accordance with the relevant plans prior to 1968, completion of the scheme so approved would be lawful.” 

28 September 2010  

Ronw Uchaf, Pontgarreg, Llandysul, Ceredigion SA44 6AU 

APP/D6820/X/10/2128460 

Proposed and existing use of yard, land and buildings for storage and recycling of scrap metal and end of life vehicles.  

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

28 September 2010  

Sharps Hay, Green Lane, Churchdown, Gloucestershire, GL3 2LB 

APP/G1630/X/10/2127574 

Part 2, Class B - Erection of a double garage, proposed vehicular access and permeable parking/ turning area. 

Dealt with Part 2, Class B.   Inspector stated that “substantial ground excavation and the maintenance of ground levels by large retaining walls … are engineering operations which … are significant in scale and exceed works that could reasonably be regarded as incidental to the provision of a means of access”.  

28 September 2010  

Dixie , Chelveston Road, Stanwick, Raunds, Wellingborough, NN9 6PU 

APP/G2815/X/09/2117504 

Siting of a mobile home for residential use. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

6 October 2010  

Plot 3E, Beech House Farm, Beech House Lane, Salehurst, Robertsbridge, East Sussex TN32 5PN 

APP/U1430/X/10/2121477 

Lawful Development Certificate in respect of land which has been cultivated and therefore caravan used for storage. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

8 October 2010  

120 Hampden Road , London N8 0HS  

APP/Y5420/X/10/2120652 

Use of property as two self contained flats. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

13 October 2010  

The Jennings Yard, Monk Sherborne Road, Sherborne St John, Basingstoke, Hampshire, RG24 9LH 

APP/H1705/X/10/2125988 

Use of land as builders yard 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

19 October 2010  

Ashfield Farm, Howe Green, HERTFORD, Hertfordshire SG13 8LJ 

APP/J1915/X/10/2122572 

Use for non agricultural storage and for vehicle and equipment maintenance workshop. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

20 October 2010  

Hill Cottage Farm Camping and Caravan Park, Sandleheath Road, Alderholt, Dorset SP6 3EG 

APP/U1240/X/10/2121284 

Use of land for camping purposes (tents and caravans) for the period April to October (inclusive) each year. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

25 October 2010  

5 Gilnow Road , Bolton BL1 4LH  

APP/N4205/X/10/2129617 

The proposed additional use of a dwelling house as a base for taking telephone bookings for the operation of two private hire vehicles 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

25 October 2010  

Dunmurry, Goodeve Road, Bristol BS9 1PR 

APP/Z0116/X/10/2131939 

The construction of gates and piers. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

27 October 2010  

Land at OS 93, Near Dinmor, Penmon, Anglesey, LL58 8SN 

APP/L6805/X/10/2128727 

Proposed use for 2 dwellings 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

27 October 2010  

8 Eden Court , Watford, Northamptonshire NN6 7UW 

APP/Y2810/X/09/2119278 

Retention of 1.8m high boundary fence 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

1 November 2010  

Dwelling knofwn as Maesaran, Kerry, Powys SY16 4DW 

APP/T6850/X/10/2124973 

Use of dwelling without complying with condition no. 11 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

1 November 2010  

1 Ridehalgh Street , Colne, BB8 8DW  

APP/E2340/X/10/2124054 

The use of the land for car parking. 

The appeal dealt with whether a piece of land in front of the front garden is within the “curtilage” of the property, whether evidence of a previous building on this land affects this, and whether an LDC can be issued in breach of an enforcement notice. 

1 November 2010  

Ivy Cottage Mobile Home Park , Within Lane, Hopton, Staffordshire, ST18 

OLP 

APP/Y3425/X/09/2115020 

Use as a caravan site for the stationing of residential caravans, etc 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

3 November 2010  

Tollgate Holiday Bungalows, Duver Road, Seaview, Isle of Wight PO34 5AJ 

APP/P2114/X/10/2126639 

LDC sought for permanent residential use. 

The Inspector explained the tests for how to interpret a planning permission decision notice. 

9 November 2010  

Storage yard adjoining Pilning Station, Station Road, Pilning, Bristol BS35 4JT 

APP/P0119/X/10/2125474 

The existing use of land for storage of containers. (Class B8 as defined in the Town and Country Planning (Use Classes) Order 1987 as amended). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

9 November 2010  

Beans Meadow, Nottingham Road, Heronsgate, Hertfordshire WD3 5DP 

APP/P1940/X/10/2124090 

Use of cabin as dwelling. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

11 November 2010  

Arch Farm Barn, Woolpit Road, Norton, Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk, IP31 

3LX 

APP/W3520/X/10/2123158 

Use and occupation of Arch Farm Barn and its curtilage as a dwelling. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

12 November 2010  

Land on the south side of Epperstone Road, Lowdham, NG14 7BZ 

APP/B3030/X/10/2125071 

Section 192 application for certification for a lawful development certificate as market garden and sale of produce from existing buildings. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 November 2010  

Land adjacent to Highgate Road, Edge Lane, Colden, Hebden Bridge, 

HX7 7PF 

APP/A4710/X/10/2126756 

Single dwelling house 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

18 November 2010  

1 Kingfield Street , London E14 3DD  

APP/E5900/X/10/2124120 

Certificate of Lawfulness in respect of existing use of studio units A-G for residential purposes. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

19 November 2010  

73 The Crescent, Stockport SK3 8SL 

APP/C4235/X/10/2132351 

Use of the premises as a Children's Home for up to 4 young people and 2 carers. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

22 November 2010  

Land between and to rear of 120c and 121a Charlton Park, Midsomer Norton, Radstock BA3 4BP 

APP/F0114/X/10/2129713 

The erection of two bungalows and garages in accordance with planning permission WN/004187/B dated 6 January 1995. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

23 November 2010  

Orcheton House Farm, Wood Lane, Heskin, CHORLEY, PR7 5PA 

APP/D2320/X/10/2133562 

Single storey extensions to existing dwellings – Inspector concluded that property was not a “dwellinghouse” and that extensions would not be within the “curtilage”. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

23 November 2010  

Land between 77 and 81 The Farthings, Astley Village, CHORLEY 

APP/D2320/X/10/2133380 

Siting of a wheeled container/store. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

23 November 2010  

39 Edwards Road, Whitley Bay, NE26 2BH 

APP/W4515/X/10/2121958 

Use of existing dwelling house property as a dwelling for three residents living together and acting as a single household at 39 Edwards Road Whitley Bay, Tyne and Wear NE26 2BH. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

25 November 2010  

The Bog, Whitmead Lane, Tilford, Farnham GU10 2BP 

APP/R3650/X/10/2130245 

Use of two principle buildings as a single dwelling house. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

25 November 2010  

First, second and third floors, 11 Charlotte Place, London W1T 1SJ 

APP/X5210/X/10/2124828 

Use of 5 non-self contained household units as 3 self-contained household residential 

units 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

29 November 2010  

Land at Nant y Felin, Swansea West Industrial Park, Fforestfach, Swansea SA5 4HL 

APP/B6855/X/10/2130846 

B2 (Industrial) and B8 (Storage) uses within specific areas of the site. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

30 November 2010  

1 Devonshire Road , Ilford IG2 7EN  

APP/W5780/X/10/2129086 

Retention of existing outbuilding and use as a separate dwelling. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

7 December 2010  

Wyland International Angling Centre, Powdermill Lane, Battle, TN33 0SU 

APP/U1430/X/10/2123485 

Lawful use for the land for the siting of two caravans for the purpose of providing holiday accommodation. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

8 December 2010  

The Caravan, Coolam Barn, Tosside, Skipton BD32 4SD 

APP/C2708/X/10/2131984 

Use of static caravan as a dwelling for unrestricted residential use. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

8 December 2010  

100 Brampton Road , London NW9 9DD  

APP/T5150/X/10/2123245 

Erection of a building to be used for storage / gym.  The part of the decision notice that relates to PD concerns the previous version of Part 1. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

9 December 2010  

Land at Prince of Wales Dry Dock, Swansea Docks, Swansea SA1 1SF 

APP/B6855/X/10/2126512 

The proposed use is Class B2 for the repair, dismantling, recycling and breaking up of ship and marine units. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

9 December 2010  

Land at Phoenix Wharf, Swansea Docks, Swansea SA1 1SF 

APP/B6855/X/10/2126518 

The proposed use is Class B2 for the repair, dismantling, recycling and breaking up of ship and marine units. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

14 December 2010  

Demartino Restaurant, 196-198 Great Portland Street, London, W1W 5QF 

• 

APP/X5990/X/10/2133033 

Use of the public highway for the placing of tables and chairs in an area measuring 1.5m x 3.25m in connection with the existing restaurant. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

14 December 2010  

White Owl Farm, Hundreds Road, Crowland, Peterborough, PE6 0LG 

APP/J0540/X/10/2131744 

Siting of mobile home used as granny annexe. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

14 December 2010  

The Oaks, Lyne Lane, Chertsey, Surrey KT16 0AL 

APP/Q3630/X/10/2125733 

Increase in storage on the site from 2 boats, 1 motor vehicle and 1 caravan to 3 boats, 3 caravans and 5 motor vehicles. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

14 December 2010  

The Oaks, Lyne Lane, Chertsey, Surrey KT16 0AL 

APP/Q3630/X/10/2125738 

To increase the number of motor vehicles for sale at the site from one to five at any one time. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

14 December 2010  

1 Treeside Place , Cranley Gardens, London N10 3AR 

APP/Y5420/X/10/2124572 

Creation of patio/hardstanding in garden (to be finished in brick pavers). 

The main issue was whether the property still benefited from permitted development rights, particularly in light of an alleged breach of a condition of the original planning permission for the property. 

15 December 2010  

Land opposite Boundary Farm, London Road, Hurst Green TN19 7QY 

APP/U1430/X/10/2127091 

The applicants proposed use is that of keeping livestock in the stables & when housed as such, monitoring their welfare full time by way of time shifts & in such time expended pursuing a minor ancillary non-commercial use in art & craft. For the sake of clarity this would involve the full time occupation of the barn & stables 24 hours per day. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

15 December 2010  

394 High Road , Harrow, Middlesex, HA3 6HJ 

APP/M5450/X/10/2125544 

The proposed use of the side extension of the dwellinghouse for odffice and design of cosmetic jewellery (Class B1) employing three (3) full time and one (1) part time employees between 9:30 Hours to 17:00 Hours. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 December 2010  

170 Commercial Road , London, E1 2JY  

APP/E5900/X/10/2128782 

Retention of retail use on ground floor and conversion of first to third floors to a self-contained flat. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

17 December 2010  

75-91 Shaftesbury Avenue and 52-53 Dean Street, London W1D 5DU 

APP/X5990/X/10/2128950 

Use of 10 car parking spaces at basement level for commercial purposes. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

22 December 2010  

13 Pensford Close, Crowthorne, Berkshire RG45 6QR 

APP/X0360/X/10/2133575 

The proposed conversion of existing garage to habitable accommodation to form a one bedroom annexe. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

22 December 2010  

10 Clayton Park, Hassocks, West Sussex BN6 8JQ 

APP/D3830/X/10/2129987 

The addition of a pitched roof over the garage in place of the existing flat roof; the addition of a pitched roof over the porch in place of the existing flat roof and the addition of a handrail and balustrade around the existing balcony (Balcony and access door formed in September 2008).  The application was assessed against the previous version of Part 1 of the GPDO. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

22 December 2010  

Higher Park, Iddesleigh, Winkleigh, Devon EX19 8BS 

APP/Q1153/X/10/2128902 

Determination of whether existing structure on-site is a "mobile unit". 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

29 December 2010  

Northern part of the former Cape Boards Site, Iver Lane, Uxbridge, UB8 2SR 

APP/R5510/X/10/2125095 

Marking out on existing tarmac of 25 lorry parking spaces. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

31 December 2010  

Land adjacent to Lower Milton, Payhembury, Devon, EX14 3HE 

APP/U1105/X/10/2128622 

Use of land to site a residential caravan. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

31 December 2010  

Myatt & Leason, Old Mill Street, Stoke-on-Trent ST4 2RP 

APP/M3455/X/10/2123872 

To use premises as retail (Use Class A1) with ancillary workshop. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

10 January 2011  

Cedar Lodge, Headley Road, Epsom KT18 6BH 

APP/P3610/X/10/2133366 

Use as a dwellinghouse without complying with conditions 12 and 16 attached to planning permission 83/0826/0396 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

10 January 2011  

17 College Crescent , London NW3 5LL  

APP/X5210/X/10/2131829 

Re-arrangement and use of property as 9 bed-sitting rooms (each with kitchen area and shower room) with communal utility room and store room and two self-contained flats. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

11 January 2011  

The Log Cabin, Four Oaks, Ivy Barn Lane, Margaretting, CM4 0EW 

APP/W1525/X/10/2127194 

Use as a single dwelling 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

12 January 2011  

Burleyhayes Linhay, Hemyock, Cullompton, Devon, EX15 3UL 

APP/Y1138/X/10/2129483 

The existing use of a former agricultural linhay for storage/recreational use in association with the existing nearby dwelling known as 'Burleyhayes Cottage'. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

17 January 2011  

Land adjacent to Leckford Hutt, London Road, Leckford, Hants SO20 6DE 

APP/C1760/X/10/2125334 

Proposed increase from 5 to 15 caravans 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

18 January 2011  

397 Wimborne Road East , Ferndown, Dorset, BH22 9LZ 

APP/U1240/X/10/2135177 

Construction of the most westerly of the two dwellings approved under planning 

permission 3/90/0319 in accordance with plans approved under this permission. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

28 January 2011  

Brooksbank Garage, Featherstone Lane, Featherstone, Pontefract, WF7 6AN 

APP/X4725/X/10/2130208 

Certificate of existing lawful use of car park ancillary to a garage (B2). 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

28 January 2011  

Gralerie Woods, South Tawton, Devon, EX20 2LR 

APP/J9497/X/10/2127979 

Construction of a forestry store. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

1 February 2011  

Court Farm House, Clapton, Crewkerne, TA18 8PU 

APP/R3325/X/10/2138801 

The use of land for the siting of a mobile home for use ancillary to main dwelling. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

1 February 2011  

11 Exmouth Road , Ruislip HA4 0UX  

APP/R5510/X/08/2083306 

Dealt with proposed extension under the previous version of Part 1. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

2 February 2011  

Hawthorn Cottage, Dobshill, Hawarden, Flintshire CH5 3LZ 

APP/A6835/X/10/2136215 

Use of Hawthorn Cottage as a single dwellinghouse in breach of condition number 3 of planning permission number 4/12/17251, dated 4 October 1988 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

7 February 2011  

22 Mill Lane , Wigginton, York, YO32 2PX 

APP/C2741/X/10/2132047 

Existing shop 

proven to have operated since 1917, to continue trading as a shop selling food 

products. No change in use 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

8 February 2011  

9 Seawick Road , St. Osyth, Clacton on Sea, CO16 8JS 

APP/P1560/X/10/2130140 

Lawful Use Application for all year round occupancy.  The Inspector looked at caselaw with respect to 4 year rule vs 10 year rule. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

18 February 2011  

62 Mangrove Road , Hertford SG13 8AN  

APP/J1915/X/10/2135567 

The development proposed is veranda to front, side dormers, rear first floor dutch roof aspect to be modified as to original approved planning permission ref. 3/07/2446/FP. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

18 February 2011  

Pound Meadow, Temple Lane, Bisham, MARLOW, SL7 1SA 

APP/T0355/X/10/2131080 

The use for which a certificate of lawful use or development is sought is D2 (or “The use of Pound Meadow for leisure purposes) 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

18 February 2011  

South Trew Stables, Highampton, Beaworthy, Devon EX21 5JG 

APP/W1145/X/10/2129644 

Use of land for the storage of caravans. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

21 February 2011  

14 Monkhams Drive, Woodford Green, IG8 0LQ  

APP/W5780/X/10/2138258 

Single storey rear extension completed September 2008. CERTIFICATE OF LAWFUL DEVELOPMENT (EXISTING) – Extension was commenced prior to 01/10/2008. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

21 February 2011  

Buttercup Barn, Palmers Road, Wootton Bridge, Ryde, IoW PO33 4NF 

APP/P2114/X/10/2127942 

Lawful Development Certificate for continued use of property as residential. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

23 February 2011  

Warren Farm, Bar Road, Curbar, Hope Valley S32 3YB 

APP/M9496/X/10/2126722 

The erection of a building which has been used as a dwelling for in excess of four years without an agricultural occupancy condition within use class C3. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

28 February 2011  

Le Van, Red Lane, Burton Green, Kenilworth, CV8 1PE 

APP/T3725/X/10/2135808 

An increase from 3 caravans to 8 caravans stationed on a lawful caravan site 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

1 March 2011  

Wildacres, Green Dene, East Horsley, Leatherhead, KT24 5RE 

APP/Y3615/X/10/2130578 

Use as a caravan ancillary to the dwellinghouse by inserting a false ceiling within the structure no higher than 3 m above the floor 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

2 March 2011  

34-35 Cadogan Place , London SW1X 9RX  

APP/K5600/X/10/2140909 

Proposed installation of a sculpture at the rear basement garden of the property – the Inspector assessed whether the sculpture constitutes “development”. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

8 March 2011  

Shipstal Cottage, Shipstal Point, Arne, Wareham, BH20 5BL 

APP/B1225/X/10/2136866 

Works to arrest the process of erosion and flooding and to sufficiently restore the level of land previously affected by this process from the sea within the domestic garden and existing sea defence barrier to an extent which secures house foundations, sewage system integrity and amenity of land. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

8 March 2011  

Reedswood Retail Park , Reedswood Way, Walsall, WS2 8XA 

APP/V4630/X/10/2135693 

Use of any 

building within the site for the sale of clothing and footwear (fashion). 

Deals with the issue of how to interpret a planning permission, and refers to a number of areas of case law, including the following: 

 

“The proper interpretation/construction of a planning permission is a matter of law for the courts and on which there is considerable judicial authority. In the case of R. v Ashford Borough Council ex parte Shepway District Council [1998] 2 PLCR 12, it was held that when construing a planning permission regard is only to be had to the permission itself, including the conditions and express reasons for imposing them. Further, a planning permission runs with the land and cannot mean one thing in the hands of one person and something else in the hands of another, as held in Slough Estates Ltd v Slough Borough Council (No. 2) [1971] AC 958; [1970] 2 WLR 1187. However, a court or an inspector should strive to overcome any difficulty in giving words in a planning permission some meaning, as held in Fawcett Properties Ltd v Buckinghamshire CC [1960] 3 All ER 503; [1960] 3 WLR 831. In that case Lord Denning said “a planning condition is only void for uncertainty if it can be given no meaning or no sensible or ascertainable meaning, and not merely because it is ambiguous or leads to absurd results”. Finally at this stage, it was held in R(Reid) v Secretary of State for Transport, Local Government and the Regions [2002] EWHC 2174 (Admin) that the legal question in construing a planning permission (or a condition to it) is not what the LPA intended to grant but what it in fact granted, and that there is no rule that planning permissions and conditions are to be construed narrowly or strictly as held in Hall & Co Ltd v Shoreham-by-Sea DC [1964] 1 WLR 240 at 245.” 

8 March 2011  

2 Holland Road , London W14 8BA  

APP/K5600/X/10/2132193 

The erection of a poster panel 4.5m x 3m 

The Inspector considered whether the advert was granted deemed consent by either Class 6 or Class 12 of the Advert Regs. 

9 March 2011  

Castle Piece Stables Eastbury Hungerford Berkshire RG17 7RJ 

APP/W0340/X/10/2138208 

The dwelling to be occupied by a person solely or mainly employed full-time in horse training or a dependant of such a person residing with that person on the land identified in this planning permission 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

10 March 2011  

Lone Barn, Stoke Lyne, Bicester, Oxon, OX27 8SD 

APP/C3105/X/10/2139726 

Use of building as a single dwellinghouse and surrounding land as residential curtilage 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

10 March 2011  

Adams Well, Colchester Road, Assington, Sudbury CO10 5LX 

APP/D3505/X/10/2134344 

Proposed use of a farm building as a shop. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

11 March 2011  

104 Stoke Newington Church Street, London N16 0LA 

APP/U5360/X/10/2128480 

Use of the 

basement as a social club. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

16 March 2011  

197 Botley Road , Burridge, Fareham SO31 1BJ 

APP/A1720/X/10/2137071 and APP/A1720/X/10/2138658 

Storage of cabins, plant, caravans and building materials and the repair and servicing of builders plant, machines and motor vehicles and the assembly and fabrication of building components. 

No further notes – decision notice not downloaded. 

17 March 2011  

Basement flat, 118 Camden Road, London, NW1 9EE 

APP/X5210/X/10/2139147 

Use of basement as a self contained resident